Do I stay, or do I go?
It’s one of the toughest questions a pastor has to face.
Pastoring isn’t easy. There will always be difficulties to address and bad history to overcome. But most pastors are in it for the long haul.
I’ve spent 33 years at my current church (more about that in point 8), but before that I left two short-term pastorates. One with great sorrow, wondering why the Lord hadn’t called us to stay longer. The other in great pain, wondering why God called us there to begin with.
The reasons for both have become clearer as the years have passed. Including the opportunity to help others by sharing the lessons I learned.
Staying Is the Default
In this article, I’m offering a list of reasons to leave a pastorate, rather than a list of reasons to stay, but staying should always be our default choice, as I’ve written in several posts, including Transition Without Relocation: 8 Steps to Stay Fresh In a Long-Term Pastorate.
But here are eight good reasons it might be time to leave your current church:
(Obviously, these only apply when the congregation and pastor have a say in pastoral placement. If your denomination assigns pastors to churches, that’s all you need to know whether to stay or leave.)
1. You’ll Never Be More than a Hired Hand
The shepherd has a relationship to the sheep. The hired hand doesn’t.
Jesus is our example in that.
When a pastor comes to an existing church, it can take a several years to become a true part of the family dynamic of the congregation. But you should know within a year or two if it’s moving in that direction or not.
Some pastors remain hired hands by their own choices and emotional bearing. But most want to be true under-shepherds, becoming an integral part of the church family.
Some congregations won’t ever let the pastor in emotionally. Usually it’s a defense mechanism they’ve adapted after being burned by too many pastoral departures.
But the congregation that won’t let a new pastor in, won’t be very welcoming to guests either. So they’ll never obey the Great Commission and will never be a healthy church.
This can be especially true of smaller, more rural churches and towns (sorry for the stereotype). In many of them, if you don’t have a generational connection, you’ll always be an outsider. They may treat you politely, but you’ll always be more like a guest in their home than a member of the family.
I don’t believe the true role of pastor can be fulfilled as a hired hand. If it becomes obvious that’s all you’ll ever be, it’s probably time to leave.
2. You Can No Longer Trust the Church Leadership
I won’t work with people I can’t trust.
In one church I started with very little salary. The church had been through tough times. Tithes had dried up. But I was told, in writing, that if I hit certain ministry and fiscal goals for the church, they would pay me a wage on which I could support my family.
When the time came, the church hadn’t just hit the goals, we had exceeded them. But the church leaders broke their promise to me. One of them told me, “I don’t care what you have in writing. You’re not getting an extra penny.” Yes, in those exact words.
It’s not about the money. It’s about trust. If I can’t trust the leaders, I won’t work with them.
At some point their lack of truthfulness would undermine my integrity, too. That is something I will never allow. And neither should you.
3. Your Family Would Pay too Steep a Price
The details of this one are still too painful to relate, but I’ll say this. Disagree with me all you want. Tell me to my face and let’s deal with the issue. But when you do something to hurt my kids because you disagree with me . . .
Pastoral ministry must always put God first, family second, church third. It’s not always easy to be in a pastor’s family. And there will always be a price to pay. But there are lines that should never be crossed.
4. You Love them, But Don’t Like Them
The “should we leave?” meeting is one of the hardest conversations a pastor and spouse will ever have.
Shelley and I have had two of them (three, if you count the assistant pastor position I left to become a lead pastor).
At one of them, we realized that staying and helping the church turn around would be long, painful, and costly to us and our family. After assessing the situation, I blurted out “Well, that’s it, then. I don’t like these people enough to do that for them.” I didn’t know I felt it until I heard myself say it.
I didn’t tell the church that, of course. That would have been hurtful and unloving. I haven’t told anyone that until now – at least not in writing.
Yes, we’re supposed to love one another as believers. But that doesn’t mean we’ll like everyone. And no, a pastor doesn’t have to like everyone in the church. But pastoring a church is hard enough when you do like everyone. It’s unbearable – and maybe impossible – if you can’t bring yourself to like the people you’re sacrificing so much for.
5. Your Leadership has Lost Its Moral Authority
We can lose our moral authority in many ways.
And it’s not always the pastor’s fault.
Pastoring isn’t about exerting your dominance. But once people have lost respect in your ability to lead, it’s virtually impossible to gain it back, and it’s time to go.
6. Your Gifts No Longer Match the Church’s Needs
Our leadership gifts have to match the leadership needs of a congregation. Sometimes the pastor/church relationships starts that way, but changes for a variety of factors.
As long as the church and pastor keep adapting together, they can weather almost any storm and stay together for a long, long time. But if they stop matching up, even a dynamic, gifted pastor in a healthy, loving church can’t make it work.
We‘ve all seen too many examples of pastors that hung on long after they stopped being effective. Don’t let it happen to you. Or your church.
7. Your Ministry Was Scaffolding
Some pastorates are meant to be short-term. Like scaffolding on the outside of a building under construction, they provide support during critical times of startup or turnaround, then they move on to another task.
One of our pastorates was that. We took the church as far as we were capable of, then left it for others to build upon.
I have a friend who was scaffolding at a small church in a racially transitional community. The city, which had historically been mostly white and middle class (like him), had become mostly Filipino and working class. But the church stayed mostly white and was dying.
My friend pastored there long enough to help the congregation open its doors to the neighborhood. He mentored Filipino leaders. In a few years, the church became heavily Filipino. So he left it in the hands of the Filipino leadership. Today, it’s a thriving church that reflects the racial mix of the community.
8. It’s Time to Transition
This is what happened to me.
After 25 years as the lead pastor of our current church, we knew it was time to step aside and let someone else lead. For us, it was a combination of things, including the growing ministry of Helping Small Churches Thrive, the availability/willingness of the next generation of leadership, and more.
In the eight years since then, we’ve been blessed to work with and learn under the church’s current leadership, which has a great start on long-term viability.
The best indicator for creating generational church health is transitioning smoothly from one long-term pastor to the next.
Check out these podcast episodes about our pastoral transition:
- Pastoral Longevity and Ministry Partnership, with Gary Garcia (Ep 16)
- Pastoral Transition, with Gary Garcia (Ep 17)
- The Value of Pastoral Longevity, Gary Garcia Interviews Karl Vaters (Ep 64)
Give the Long Haul Your Best Try
Sometimes what works for a while, like the above scaffolding, changes over time. But in most situations, the church and the pastor grow together, pulling each other forward as God guides each one.
When I think back to how naïve and inexperienced I was when they hired me 33 years ago, it makes me wonder what they were thinking. (On the other hand, if I had thought too long about the mess they were in at the time, it might make me wonder why I took the job.)
We suited each other then. We’re both different now. But, like a good marriage, we became different together. They’re better because of what God has done for them through me. I am certainly better because of what God has done for me through them.
The path hasn’t been easy. But it’s been worth it.
If you’re wondering whether-or-not it’s your time to move on, don’t use this article as a final word on anything. Pray about it. Seek wise counsel.
Ultimately, it’s God who puts pastors in churches. And it’s God who removes us.
Stay if you can. But if you need to leave, do so with grace, love, and integrity.
(Photo by Marco Nürnberger | Flickr)
