The 3 Best Seasons for Bringing Change to a Church

underwater church

It’s not always easy to fix long-term problems and implement needed changes in a church – especially when old, dysfunctional ways have taken root.

Sometimes we make our job harder than it needs to be, not by doing the wrong things, but by doing the right things at the wrong time.

Solomon said it best, in what may be the greatest change passage in the bible, when he told us, “There is a time for everything, and a season for every activity under heaven: … a time to plant and a time to uproot … a time to tear down and a time to build … a time to keep and a time to throw away … a time to tear and a time to mend…” – Ecclesiastes 3:1-8

For every needed change, there is a right season. So how do we know when that season is?

Over the years, I’ve discovered three simple principles that have helped me and my church. They’re found in the following old fable. 


The Leaky Cabin – A Fable

A man goes to visit an old friend who lives in a cabin in the woods. By the time he arrives, it’s pouring rain and he’s soaking wet. When his friend answers the door, he jumps inside, glad to get out of the rain, only to find that the cabin roof is leaking and dripping water all over the place.

The newcomer asks about the leaky roof and all the buckets, pots, cans and other containers noisily catching water. “Oh that,” responds the host. “I barely notice it any more. You just get used to the rain in this part of the country.”

“Why don’t we go up on the roof and fix the leaks? I’d be happy to help,” offers the newcomer.

“No,” his friend replies. “It’s dangerous on the roof in the rain. Plus, it’s getting dark. Let’s do it later.”

The man agrees. After a drippy, damp night of fitful sleep, they wake up to a beautiful sunny day. The visitor turns to his friend and says, “hey buddy, let’s grab some breakfast, then get that roof repaired!”

To which his friend responds, “Why? It’s not leaking now.”


How and When to Tackle the Long-Term Problems

That fable is an unfortunate reality in a lot of people’s lives and ministries. When things go wrong, we’re too busy stopping the flood from overtaking us to do any long-term repairs. But when the crisis is over, we forget about the problems and keep on as if everything is fine.

In a previous post, Unhealthy Churches Should Not Act Like Healthy Churches – Until They Are, I wrote about how we need to pastor dysfunctional churches differently in the short-term – much like putting out buckets while it’s raining. So, the cabin owner was right when he said the middle of a rainstorm is not the best time to fix a leaky roof.

But when is the right time?


1. As Soon as You See the Problem

The best time to fix a big problem is when it’s still a small one.

If the cabin owner had kept a regular roof maintenance schedule, no one would have lost a moment of sleep from a leaky roof.

Problems that get delayed don’t go away. They get worse. Then they become invisible to us. If the cabin owner’s friend lives there for too long without repairing the roof, he’ll stop hearing the drips, too.

Many church leaders can become like the cabin owner, if we’re not careful. Things get bad, then stay bad, so we get used to it and resign ourselves to living in a broken church because “it rains a lot here”.

The truth is, it rains a lot in every church. Let’s not get used to offering excuses, instead of working on solutions.

You can’t stop the rain, but you can fix the roof.

Churches with obvious, chronic dysfunctions can’t keep new people because they can’t stand the drip, drip, drip of unaddressed problems.

Long-time members don’t pitch in and help out because they’ve gotten used to it.

Sometimes, the person who sees the problems most readily is the guest. We need to resist the temptation to act like we know better because we’ve been around longer. Fresh eyes can bring a helpful perspective on problems we’ve gotten used to. A wise church leader will listen to new voices and fix leaks they didn’t know they had.

If you’re the new pastor with new eyes, fixing chronic problems requires wisdom. Fix the problems you can. But when you get resistance on other problems, don’t give up. Write them down, then wait for a better season to tackle them.

Such as…


2. Immediately Following a Crisis

Right after a crisis, people are much more aware of the need for change. First thing in the morning on a sunny day following the storm.

As Winston Churchill famously said, “Never let a good crisis go to waste.”

I’ve also heard people say, “God never wastes a hurt.” Instead, he redeems them. If we let him.

Good leaders let the storm pass without causing further disruption in people’s lives. Then they seize the moment on the morning after the storm, so problems don’t repeat.

In addition to recovering from crises, it’s always good to have an assessment of every event, especially the big, new ones, as soon as possible after they happen. Get honest feedback on what went well and what could have gone better, before people forget. Then devise a plan to do it better the next time around.

People don’t think as clearly or work as well when they’re in the middle of emotional highs or lows. But there’s a lot of clarity on the morning after the storm passes.


But Don’t Create a Crisis

There are some leadership gurus who would tell you to create a crisis that you can take advantage of. I profoundly disagree with that on many levels.

Life is filled with enough challenges on its own, without us creating false ones. Besides, creating a false crisis is dishonest, manipulative and very likely to blow back in your face when it’s found out. Redeem the hurt, don’t create more.


3. When Everything Is Going Great

When’s the best time to fix a leaky roof? When the roof isn’t leaking.

Healthy churches are always looking for ways to make good things better. They don’t wait for something to break before they fix it. They keep fixing it so that it doesn’t break.

Life will bring unforeseen challenges. Bad things happen to good people – and to good churches. We can’t work or pray our way out of that reality.

But let’s not add to the difficulties by not fixing the things we can fix.

No, this isn’t easy. When the church is in an “up” season, no one wants to revisit problems. Especially if the “ups” are rare. But that’s when they can be dealt with the most easily and honestly.

Just like a healthy body fights off diseases better than a sick one, a healthy church uses its strengths to fix its weaknesses.


So what do you think? Do you have any other times that have worked well for your church to implement change?

We want to hear from you. Yes, you!
Enter your comment right below this post and get in on the conversation.

(Underwater Church photo from Juan Tello • Flickr • Creative Commons license) 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

7 thoughts on “The 3 Best Seasons for Bringing Change to a Church”

  1. Good post Karl! For someone who had to overcome a slight fear of “conflict” if someone didn’t agree with me, this was very positive. The time to do projects is truly when the sun is shining!

  2. This really resonates with me. I have been pastoring in a small church for the past 6 years (4 as student pastor, then the last 2 as senior pastor). The life of our church has been somewhat of a roller coaster with many ups and downs.

    We are currently in a “down” place. Attendance has dwindled (again), finances are less than ideal, struggling to keep volunteers in critical areas (i.e. kids’ ministry) core families have left for a variety of reasons (job relocation, new church, etc).

    We have sort of existed in the “leaky roof” condition for years and now we have found ourselves at a critical point of needing to fix the roof. I have recently stumbled upon your website and am very grateful for the articles you have written. They have been an encouragement. I look forward to scouring the rest of your site for ideas on how to move our unhealthy small church to a place of health and growth!

    Grace and peace.

    1. Glad you found us, Jerannon. There are a lot more churches facing struggles like yours than we’re usually comfortable admitting. I designed this site to be a safe place for pastors and churches like you and yours to get some encouragement and insight and connection.

  3. This so applies in our own lives as well as the lives of the church! This would make a great Sunday lesson (spoken from someone who needed to hear it!)

  4. Pingback: leaking roof as window to life | kingdom travelin'

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *